American Restaurant in Key West

Sarabeth's in Key West

Posh chain serving American fare, including brunch & dessert. Some offer dinner & cocktails.

Grand Cafe Key West

Creative New American fare & a broad wine list served in a Victorian mansion with a garden & porch.

Southernmost Beach Café

Beachfront, open-air cafe serving American fare amid ocean blue walls, French cafe chairs & a bar.

Fogarty's

Casual bar & grill offering American fare & local seafood, plus a variety of frozen drinks.

Blue Heaven

Iconic landmark for Floridian-Caribbean cuisine & key lime pie, with a funky setting.

Caroline's Cafe

American cafe serving po' boys, conch fritters & the like in a circa-1838 house with outdoor seats.

Mr. Z's

Counter-serve joint dishing thin-crust pizzas, stromboli & Philly cheesesteaks in laid-back digs.

Jack Flats

Laid-back venue with a long bar & booths offering home-style surf 'n' turf plus sports on TV.

Tin Cup Chalice Bar & Grill

Two Friends Patio Restaurant

Long-standing mostly outdoor cafe with an old-school American menu plus lively karaoke.

Margaritaville - Key West

Lively joint offers island-inspired fare & margaritas plus a gift shop & live music most nights.

Square Grouper Key West

Pepe's Cafe

Rustic joint with laid-back vibes dishing up signature breakfasts plus surf 'n' turf since 1909.

Rams Head Southernmost

Vibrant open-air bar with patio seating, offering seafood, sandwiches, and cocktails, plus live music.

Tavern N Town

Sophisticated bi-level dining room with an open kitchen serving tapas & Key West-inspired entrees.

Harpoon Harry's

Cash-only diner offering hearty American comfort food in a cheerful atmosphere with quirky accents.

Dion's Quik Chik

Conch Flyer

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

Airy stop for seafood & elevated comfort cuisine like crab beignets plus cocktails & water views.

Mary Ellen's Bar & Restaurant with Bad Boy Burrito

Upbeat watering hole with a cool vibe & comfort eats including gourmet grilled cheese.